UNION OF COUNCILS’ CENTRAL ASIAN
HUMAN RIGHTS INFORMATION NETWORK
MARKAZIY OSIYO INSON HUQUQLARI AHBOROT MARKAZI
1819 H Street NW, Suite #230 Washington, DC, 20006
Abdumannob Polat: Ph. (202) 775-9770, ext 17; Fax (202) 775-9776
E-mail:polat@ucsj.com, Abdumannob@hotmail.com
In Cooperation with
The Human Rights Society of Uzbekistan
O’zbekiston Inson Huquqlari Jamiyati
September 1, 1999
UZBEKISTAN:
LIST OF:
14 POSSIBLE POLITICAL PRISONERS WHO DIED IN JAIL,
5 DISAPPEARENCES, AND
505 POSSIBLE POLITICAL PRISONERS
INTRODUCTION
Most prisoners listed below have likely been jailed for their non-violent religious or political activities. Others may have committed minor violations of the law, but it is strongly believed that the severity of their sentences is disproportionate to the severity of their alleged crimes. There is no credible evidence that any of these prisoners have committed violent or serious crimes. The prosecution of many of these prisoners is clearly politically motivated and in many cases is a result of the government's campaign against the independent Islamic movement. Because we are not able to document the cases of all "common" prisoners whose rights have been severely violated, or who are believed to be innocent, we have prepared a list of prisoners who are believed to have been jailed solely for political or religious reasons. There are probably many more possible political prisoners whose prosecution has not been reported. This list therefore may only be the proverbial tip of the iceberg.
There have been numerous reports that the police routinely plant narcotics, weapons and anti-government literature, in the pockets, cars or homes of suspects. In Uzbekistan, such illegal activity by the police is common practice in the general fight against crime. Frequently, evidence of a defendant's guilt is not necessary to find him guilty. Often, a credible connection between the crime and the defendant does not exist at all. Defendants, especially in cases where there is no evidence to support the charges against them, are often beaten, tortured and subjected to psychological degradation and intimidation in order to obtain confessions. According to statements made by several possible political prisoners, methods of torture include electric shocks, beatings with batons, and use of plastic bags to temporarily suffocate victims. Reportedly, police officers put plastic bags or gas masks on a suspect blocking access to air for about a minute. Some prisoners stated that they were threatened with rape, including the rape of wives and daughters in front of them.
According to many reports, law enforcement agencies and the judiciary are both corrupt and subservient to the government's orders both in politically motivated or religion-related cases, and even in "common" criminal cases. As in many other ex-Soviet states, conditions in jails and forced labor camps are overcrowded and extremely inhumane.
The law in Uzbekistan, following the Soviet tradition, requires that a search or arrest be sanctioned by the procurator's office or by a judge, and that witnesses be present during the search and sign an affidavit stating that they witnessed the search. However, also following Soviet tradition, the authorities often illegally bring their own "witnesses" to "watch" a search. In most of the cases documented below, police violated these provisions of the law related to searches.
Most of the prisoners listed below have several young children, and their wives are usually unemployed. In Uzbekistan today, even the majority of employed people earn only enough income to pay for the traditional food of poor people in the country (bread and tea) and local public transportation. Therefore, the families of many of these prisoners have almost nothing to live on. Additionally, in many cases, the courts have confiscated the property of sentenced prisoners.
Before the February 16, 1999 bombings in Toshkent (Tashkent), the capital of Uzbekistan, many possible political prisoners had been accused of possession of narcotics or weapons, allegedly planted by the police. After February 16th, authorities more widely began to use the charges such as "conspiracy to overthrow the constitutional system" and "calls to forcibly overthrow the government." These charges are based on leaflets and other materials, also often reportedly planted by the police. Thus, the political motivation of these prosecutions is clearer.
Many of these opposition documents contain criticism of government policies and non-violent advocacy of an Islamic or democratic system. Some of them, however, including leaflets of the Hisbi-Al-Tahrir party in Uzbekistan and statements of the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan in exile, claim that president Karimov is a Jew and "a Jewish kafur [kofir] (infidel)" and that this "is why he is in favor of the West, Christians and Israel, and suppressing, in cooperation with the Israel security service Sohnut, Islam and the Islamic movement." (Excerpts from Hisbi-Al-Tahrir party’s leaflets disseminated in Uzbekistan in April-July of 1999; see also statements of the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan in exile at: FBIS, Central Eurasia – Central Asia, 04/12/1999).
The statements quoted above well could be classified as "inciting interethnic or inter-confessional hatred," making the responsible individuals and groups liable to be prosecuted according to Uzbek law and international norms, nevertheless torture must be condemned regardless of the charges, and 10-15 year jail terms for such offenses are disproportionately severe. Moreover, most prisoners listed here had no connections to such offenses whatsoever.
Similarly, many of the individuals charged with involvement in the February 16th bombings and other criminal activities are believed to be innocent. In reaction to the bombings, the Uzbek government has harassed thousands of citizens, including many non-violent opposition figures. It is still unclear whether the real culprits are in custody. It is also unclear who was behind February terrorist attack in Toshkent.
People listed below are possible political prisoners. However, this does not mean that the Union of Councils’ Central Asian Human Rights Information Network (CAHRIN) shares or supports their views or actions. Moreover, in many cases, we strongly disagree with the anti-Western and anti-American spirit, and the anti-democratic ideas advocated by these groups, such as Islamic theocratic rule in Uzbekistan and in the entire Moslem world, and the re-establishment of an Islamic Khalifate. In addition, CAHRIN condemns antisemitic statements of Hisbi-Al-Tahrir party and Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan as most likely violations of the law that warrant fair trials and reasonable punishment of the offenders. However, we believe that the government’s continuing mass suppression of the peaceful Islamists and Moslem believers has played a major role in radicalizing the opposition.
Cases with reasonable grounds of suspicion that the prisoner was involved with violence or advocacy of violence are not included to this list.
It is highly unlikely given the pervasive of the security in Uzbekistan that the number of suspects involved in the conspiracy to organize the February 16th bombings in Toshkent could be counted in the hundreds as the Uzbek government claims. Also, if as many people oppose the government’s policies, as the government itself claims, then the government should listen to arguments of the opposition and attempt to resolve current huge economic, social and political, tension in the country, by political means, negotiations and reasonable compromise. Violence may cause further radicalization of the opposition and further politicization of Islam in the region.
The current lack of opportunities for advocacy of democracy and moderate opposition to the government, and the unfair mass suppression and harassment of Islamists, most of whom are non-violent activists, as well as the current economic crisis and ideological vacuum after the collapse of communism, increase the social base of extremism.
The members of the Human Rights Society of Uzbekistan have collected most of the information reported below. Often, authorities illegally refuse to provide information on arrested people and related charges. Many relatives of prisoners are afraid to speak with human rights monitors. These circumstances make it extremely difficult to obtain any information related to possible political prisoners. For these reasons, this report may contain some inaccurate information.
In the current economic situation, Uzbekistan is close to disaster. At the same time, the government harasses opposition and other so-called undesirable individuals, their relatives and defense lawyers. Therefore, in most cases, the prisoners listed below have not the opportunity to have independent attorneys of their choice. In some cases they were provided government lawyers, many of whom did not make an effort to adequately defend the defendant. The few independent defense lawyers who continue to represent political and religious dissenters are harassed and threatened. Often, they are not allowed access to their clients and their legal appeals are ignored. For example, defense lawyer Khamid Zaynutdinov, a well known attorney who represented several defendants whose prosecution was politically or religious motivated, has been threatened several times since 1992 and told that police can easily "find" narcotics in his pockets or in his house if he continues to defend dissidents.
Most prisoners listed below are Moslem believers. However, there were also three to five prisoners – representatives of non-traditional (for Uzbekistan) sect of Christians. On July 13, 1999, three leaders of the Christians of the Full Gospel Church (Rashid Turibaev, Parakhat Yanbibaev, and Eset Tanishev) were sentenced to ten to fifteen years of imprisonment, reportedly on drug-related charges. This practice is widely used in the general fight against "common" crimes, dissent and all undesirable individuals. Reportedly, the police planted the drugs on all three and the true offence committed by these prisoners was their religious activity. Under pressure from the West, these prisoners were reported released on August 20, 1999.
In order to keep this report to a reasonable size, we have provided only very brief descriptions of most cases.
PRISONERS WHO HAVE REPORTEDLY DIED IN JAIL OR VERY SOON AFTER BEING RELEASED
- TO’RAKHONOV [TURAKHONOV], AKHMADKHON. School teacher by profession and father of five children. Member of the banned Birlik (Unity) movement and the Independent Human Rights Organization in Namangan city. Reportedly arrested on December 29, 1998 and charged with "calls to forcibly overthrow the constitutional government." On March 5, 1999 he was sentenced to six years of imprisonment, although no evidence of his guilt had been presented. Turakhonov suffered from chronic diabetes and died on June 16th in a prison hospital in Toshkent. Reportedly, he did not receive sufficient medical treatment. A former political prisoner in 1993-95, Turakhonov was first imprisoned in December 1993 for one year and a half, reportedly after police planted narcotics in his house. He fully served his first term.
- NASREDDINOV, FAZLIDDIN (born in 1957). Participated in the strike at the Machine Building Plant in Namangan in April 1992 (see introduction notes before the case 55 below). Sentenced to eight years in prison, sentence later extended for three more years. Reportedly died in jail on May 9, 1998.
- JALILOV, AKHMADALI (born in 1941). On October 4, 1992, he was sentenced to three years in prison with confiscation of property. Before the end of his term, he received an additional sentence for alleged narcotics possession. Reportedly died in jail (heart attack). His family is in a severe financial situation.
- MAKHMUDOV, AKHMAD (born in 1947). Sentenced to three and a half years in prison, later (in jail) received an additional sentence of two and a half years. Reportedly died in jail on June 19, 1996. Makhmudov's brother saw him in jail ten days before he died and reported that he was in good health at the time. His family (with four children) is in a severe financial situation.
- ABDURASULOV, AKHMAD. Reportedly died on May 9, 1994 (lung cancer). Allegedly, he was in the group of Adolat members who were sentenced for a non-violent (although illegal) attempt to cross the CIS border (see cases ##61-64 below).
- ABDULLAEV, KHAKIMJON (born in 1935). Clergyman. Reportedly, before the end of his term he received seven more years of imprisonment (for "possession of narcotics"). Reportedly died in jail (heart attack) and after his death the additional sentence was revoked.
- SHUKUROV, ELOMON.
- MAMADALIEV MUYDIN (born in 1951). Possible death in detention. Reportedly committed suicide. Arrested on May 6, 1997. Police "discovered" a blade and 5 grams of marijuana. On June 1998, after severe beatings and torture in jail, he reportedly committed suicide. He was never allowed to meet his defense lawyer.
- KHUSANOV, DILSHOD. Resident of Toshkent. Reportedly died in January 1999.
- USMONOV, FARHOD. Arrested in early June 1999 on suspicion of connections with the banned Hizbi-Al-Tahrir party. Reportedly, he died from injuries on June 19th.
- AMINOV, MUHAMADJON (born in 1945). On February 1998, he was charged under article 248 (illegal possession of weapons) of the Criminal Code and sentenced to six years of imprisonment. Reportedly died in a prison hospital on February 7, 1999. Official documents reportedly state that Aminov's death was caused by TB, but relatives met him on September 4, 1998, and at the time he was not sick. Reportedly, Aminov's body had indications of torture. He was an active member of the Jome' Mosque in Andijon.
- ZULUNOV, OLIMJON (born in 1967). Arrested on February 10, 1999. Reportedly, the same day he was beaten by the police and driven to an unknown destination. About 10 PM he was reportedly brought back in the same car and left near his house in an extreme, life-threatening condition. He died the same night. Reportedly, his body had numerous signs of beatings and torture. His relatives are afraid to speak to human rights monitors. His wife and three children are in extreme poverty. His family's address: 18 Qo'sh Ariq community (Massiv), apartment 56, Andijon (city).
- JAMOLOV, JALOLIDDIN (born in 1963). Resided at the address: Andijon city, Klara Cetkin Street, 50, apartment 6. Reportedly, he was badly beaten during his arrest. He was released after signing statement that he would not file a compliant. On January 24, 1999, JAMOLOV reportedly committed suicide (by hanging himself). He told his family that investigators demand that he testify against Khayotullo Bobomatov (see case # 190 below).
- UMARALIEV, KHASAN ERKIN oghli. Resided with relatives in Marghilon city (mahalla Maorif, Chorbogh ko’chasi 134-b). Member of Hizbi-Al-Tahrir party. Arrested on April 15, 1999. Reportedly, he died the same day in the office of the Natonal Security Service in the city of Marghilon. Buried the next day.
DISAPPEARANCES
- O'TAEV (UTAEV), ABDULLA qori. Chairman of the Islamic Rebirth Party. Disappeared in December 1992. According to his wife, Utaev was arrested near his home, but Uzbek authorities deny having him under arrest.
- MIRZAEV, ABDUVALI (Sheikh ABDUVALI qori). A popular and respected Islamic clergyman in Andijon considered to be a Wahhabi leader. He was Imam-Khatib (Chief Clergyman) of the main mosque in Andijon. Reportedly, he was arrested by security police at the Tashkent airport, along with an assistant, Ramazon Matkarimov (see the next case below). Mirzaev advocated the organizing of Islamic education and community life free of government control. Despite relatively serious attention from the international community to the disappearance of the two Islamic activists, authorities have denied their arrests, but the two, as well as Abdulla qori Otaev (see the previous case above), have still not resurfaced. After numerous requests and complaints made by Mirzaev's relatives, and one year and half after the disappearance of the Islamic activists, the authorities published a photo of Matkarimov as a missing person, but they refused to publish Mirzaev's photo. Many monitors consider this suspicious fact to be evidence that Mirzaev was or is not being held under his own name.
- MATKARIMOV, RAMAZON. Assistant of Abduvali qori Mirzaev. Reportedly, arrested along with Mirzaev (see the previous case above).
- NE'MATJON, PARPIEV. Another assistant of Abduvali qori Mirzaev, he disappeared in September of 1997 (see case #16 above). Reportedly, he was active in attempts to conduct an independent investigation of Mirzaev's disappearance and in circulating Mirzaev's educational audio and videotapes on Islam.
- BANNOEV, ABDULAKHAT. Imam-Khatib of Ataullakhon, the main mosque in Namangan. This mosque was considered to be a center of "Wahhabism" in the province. Along with Bilolkhon Rustamov (see the case #67 below), Bannoev was considered to be the most educated and respected Islamic leader in Namangan. He disappeared in early 1998.
POSSIBLE PRISONERS OF CONSCIENCE
Human Rights Monitor and Democratic Activist Most Likely Arrested For Monitoring Politically and Religious Motivated Trials
- ODILOV [ADILOV], ISMOIL. Member of the Birlik movement and the board of the Independent Human Rights Organization of Uzbekistan. Since 1989, an active member of the democratic and human rights movement. Over the last year, he monitored trials of Islamic groups. Odilov's health raises serious concerns. Reportedly, police discovered Hisbi-Al-Tahrir leaflets during a search of his house. Odilov’s relatives claim that police planted these leaflets.
Six Women - Possible Prisoners of Conscience
(Despite President Karimov's Clear Statement That He Is Not Going To Fight With Women)
Possible Psychiatric Abuse for Political Purposes.
Since 1988, there were no reports on continuation of old Soviet tradition of using psychiatry against dissenters in Uzbekistan. The report below is the only one for last eleven years.
- YO’LDOSHEVA, wife of To'lqin qori (To'lqin Yo'ldoshev), a well known Islamic leader from Toshkent, former Imam-Khatib (Chief Clergyman) at one Toshkent’s main mosques. (see introductory note before case #47). Investigators brought her to the police headquarters, threatened her and demanded that she tell them where her husband was (he was wanted by the authorities). Reportedly, she was arrested for 30 days for "hooliganism." After her release from detention, she told many people how she was treated during her arrest, and about persecution of her family members (her son was arrested also; see case #313 below). Reportedly, authorities determined her mentally ill and put her in a psychiatric hospital.
Women - Possible Prisoners of Conscience
- RAKHIMOVA SHODIYA (born in 1955). Moslem educator. Resided at Makhtumquli Street, 3rd Drive [proyezd], 18. Arrested on February 18, 1999. Charged with the articles 159 (calls to forcibly overthrow the constitutional government) and 216 (organization of banned public groups) of the Criminal Code.
- QOSIMOVA (KOSIMOVA), MAHBUBA. Resident of Toshkent. Member of the Board of Independent Human Rights Organization of Uzbekistan, and also Birlik (Unity) People's Movement (both organizations are illegally banned). Charged with the articles 168 (fraud) and 241 (covering, sheltering or not reporting on a criminal or a crime) of the Criminal Code. On July 14, 1999, she was sentenced to five years of imprisonment and was arrested in the courtroom. Qosimova was accused of sheltering Ravshan Khamidov, who was under arrest warrant as a suspect possibly involved in the February 16th bombings in Toshkent. Khamidov was arrested at Qosimova's apartment. Police claimed that Khamidov had a grenade when he was arrested. Qosimova made two controversial statements regarding the case. She told Western diplomats that the grenade was planted by police. However, she told Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty's Uzbek Service that she had no idea that Khamidov had a grenade and was wanted by the authorities, and that if she had know that Khamidov had a weapon, or that he was wanted by the authorities, she would never allow him to stay in her apartment. Qosimova was also accused of fraud. According to some reports, a few individuals claimed that she took their money and did not return it. Also, Qosimova was denied the services of a defense lawyer during her two-three hours trial. On August 18, the Toshkent city court confirmed Qosimova’s sentence.
- RUZMETOVA, YOQUTJON. Resident of Khorazm province.
- KUTIMOVA, REJABIBI. Resident of Khorazm.
- ABDULLAEVA GULSARA. Resident of Khorazm province.
Prisoners charged with participating in "Terrorist Training" in Turkey - No Evidence of Guilt Presented
- JO’RAEV [JURAEV], MUROD [MURAD] (born in 1952). Former member of the Parliament and former mayor of the city of Muborak (in 1990-92) in Qashqadaryo (Kashkadarya) province. In February 1990, he was elected to both these positions as an independent candidate (during the perestoika and glasnost period, some independent candidates were allowed to participate in elections). An engineer by education and professional background. An advocate of democratic reforms. In March 1990, he banned the activities of the Communist Party organization in his city administration. Allegedly, Juraev was involved in attempts to organize in Turkey the training of dozens of young Uzbeks. The government claims that it was terrorist training, but the authorities did not present adequate evidence to prove the charge. Arrested in Almaty, Kazakhstan in June 1994 by Uzbek security agents. The Kazakh authorities gave their permission for the arrest, without study of his case and charges against him, thus violated Kazakh laws, both countries' international obligations, and even agreements between Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan. He was charged with "participating in a conspiracy to overthrow by force the constitutional government." He was sentenced to twelve years in prison.
- ASHUROV, ERKIN (born in 1939). Former Chief Manager of the State Tea Packaging Plant in Samarqand (Samarkand), alleged member of the banned Erk (Freedom) party. He was arrested in June 1994 in Almaty, Kazakhstan together with Murad Juraev (see previous case). His arrest was totally illegal and Kazakh authorities did not authorize it. Most likely, he had no affiliation with the alleged "terrorist training" activities in Turkey. In addition to these charges, he was accused of financial irregularities during his tenure at the Tea Packaging Plant. Sentenced to ten years in prison.
New Prisoners Affiliated With the Erk Party
Government claims that these prisoners organized a "criminal group" and insulted President Karimov of Uzbekistan in printed form. Numerous violations of law and human rights, including torture, have been reported regarding these prisoners. They were all sentenced to long prison terms. Human rights monitors, independent and foreign journalists, and even relatives of defendants were not allowed to be present in the courtroom.
- BEKJONOV, RASHID - MAMADIN oghli. Brother of Muhammad Solih, head of Erk party. Former political prisoner (in 1994-96, he was jailed for one and half years for an attempt to disseminate a leaflet calling for free and fair elections). Sentenced to 12 years.
- BEKJONOV, MUHAMMAD - MAMADIN oghli. Brother of Muhammad Solih, head of the Erk party. Sentenced to 14 years.
- MAHMUDOV [MAKHMUDOV], MAMADALI. Writer. Former possible political prisoner in 1994-96. Sentenced to 14 years.
- RO’ZIMURODOV, YUSUF. Erk party member. Sentenced to 15 years.
- SHARIPOV, NE’MAT. Sentenced to eight years.
- DIYAROV, QOBUL [KOBUL]. Member of the Birlik movement and party. Sentenced to 12 years.
Muhammad Bekjonov, Yusuf Ruzimurodov, Qobil Diyorov and Ne’mat Sharipov were arrested in Ukraine and extradited to Uzbekistan with several violations of related norms. According to defense lawyer Khamid Zaynutdinov (mentioned in the Introduction), who represented four of these defendants, the court ignored numerous violations of law during arrests and investigations of the case, and complaints made by defendants that investigators obtained their confessions under torture and CHANGED! threat of rape, and also threats to jail, rape and torture members of their families. The Cases of these prisoners received relatively serious attention from the international community.
- BEKJONOV, KOMIL - MAMADIN oghli. Also, brother of Muhammad Solih, Erk party leader. Arrested after February 16, 1999 bombings in Toshkent. In June, he was sentenced to ten years of imprisonment under charge with possession of narcotics and weapons.
Possible Political Prisoners - Secular Dissidents
- QOBULOV [KOBULOV], MELI. Former member of the Parliament and the Provincial Council of Peoples Representatives, former head of Jizzakh Province's organization of the Vatan Taraqqiyoti (Fatherland Progress) party and the Human Rights Society of Uzbekistan. Former Chairman of the Ko'tarma neighborhood's citizens association (makhalla) in the city of Jizzakh. Arrested on October 27, 1994 possibly to prevent him from running for re-election in the parliamentary elections that were scheduled for December of the same year. On October 29th, two days after his arrest, Vatan Taraqqiyoti's organization in the province nominated Qobulov for re-election. Most local people supported his candidacy. Qobulov, a retired financial officer of the KGB, reportedly conducted several independent investigations of alleged corruption in the provincial and local administrations, especially related to the leasing of agricultural land. On February 12, 1996 he was sentenced to six years in prison, but after the protest of the prosecutor, in November 1996 he received an additional sentence of four years. After several amnesties, that term was reduced by at least a quarter. Qobulov was charged with "abuse of authority," "receiving bribes," "violations of rules of using state owned land," "illegal possession of weapons and narcotics," and other charges. Human rights activists believe that Meli Qobulov is innocent and that his prosecution was politically motivated. Qobulov reportedly gave a loan to one of his associates, but when the loan was repaid the authorities labeled it a bribe.
- QO'QONOV [KUKONOV], SAMANDAR. Former member of the Uzbek parliament in 1990-93, former head of the state-owned oil company in Toshkent province. Allegedly, Qo’qonov funded some pro-democratic opposition activities, specifically those related to the Erk party. Because of these allegations, he was dismissed from his position and the authorities audited his company. He was accused of embezzlement and illegal allocations of funds for the Erk party. According to reports, he was arrested in 1993 and sentenced to twelve years in prison. There were also reports that Qoqonov was dismissed, arrested and sentenced with numerous violations of his rights and the law, including the violation of his immunity as a (then) Member of Parliament.
- USMONOV, RUSTAM. Well-known businessman. Arrested in early 1998. Reportedly, Radio Liberty's Uzbek Service aired several reports prepared by Usmonov. These reports unmasked alleged corruption in the local government in Andijon province. It is strongly believed that Usmonov was jailed for his criticism.
- QUTBITDINOVK [KUTBITDINOV], ABDURASHID. Arrested on April 7, 1996. Member of the (banned) Birlik movement, businessman. Found guilty of financial violations, but it is strongly believed that his prosecution was mainly politically motivated.
- MARDIEV, SHODI. Journalist. Reportedly arrested for reports that unmasked corruption in Samarqand [Samarkand’ province. He was charged with "offering a bribe" to a prosecutor and sentenced to ten years in prison. According to reports, after appeals and protests, including protests from the international community, his sentence term was reduced twice.
- GADOEV, PO’LAT [POLAT, PULAT]. Correspondent in Qashqadaryo province for the government newspaper Khalq So’zi (People's Word). Reportedly, he was working on an article that described false reporting to the government and corruption in the local administration. He was charged with taking bribes and abuse of authority. He was not able to get a defense lawyer and was reportedly beaten in custody.
- ODILOV, AKHMADJON. Arrested in 1992 or 1993 and sentenced in January 1994. Sentenced to nine years in prison allegedly for an attempt to organize a political party called at various times To'ron [Turon] or Temur-Adolat. However, officially Odilov was accused of embezzlement (illegal selling of four metric tons of saltpeter in 1984). During Soviet period in the 1980's, Odilov was illegally jailed for seven years and four months without a trial and released in late 1991. For many years until 1984, Odilov was the head of a State Agricultural Venture in Pop district, Namangan province. His prosecution during Uzbekistan's independence is believed to be politically motivated. Reportedly, Odilov was tortured.
Two Brothers of Avazkhon Mukhtorov, Former Principal Deputy Khokim (Governor) of Farghona [Farghona] Province, Currently Alleged Dissident
Avazkhon Mukhktorov was fired in October 1993 and immediately left Uzbekistan. In Moscow he published several books related to the problems of transition to a market economy and got a doctoral degree in economics. Some of his publications contained critical assessments of the economic situation and reforms in Uzbekistan. More importantly, there were allegations that Mukhtorov funded some activities of the opposition, especially those related to the Erk party. It is believed that these two prisoners' jailing is connected to Mukhtorov and his activities. In 1998 Avazkhon Mukhktorov was granted political asylum in the US.
- MUKHTOROV, TIMUR (born in 1942). Former senior official at the Association of Commerce and Trade in the Farghona province. Arrested in late October 1993. Charged with the embezzlement and sentenced to eleven years in prison.
- MUKHTOROV, MURTOZ [MURTAZ] (born in 1958). Former head of the police in Qo'qon (Quqon, Kokand) city, Farghona province. Arrested on September 13, 1995. Reportedly, a couple of hours before his arrest, Murtoz Mukhtorov was invited to a police station and during a friendly conversation was offered several cups of green tea. During his arrest, police searched his car and his room in Toshkent's Chorsu hotel and "discovered" narcotics, twenty cartridges and a grenade. Police immediately tested his urine and blood (although this is not a common practice), and "discovered" narcotics in them. Human rights monitors believe that the tea he was offered was laced with narcotics. He was sentenced to eight years in prison. Reportedly, his term was not cut as a result of several general amnesties because he was accused of violating prison and forced labor camp regimes. He was also accused of possessing narcotics during his stay in the special punishment cell in the jail.
Two New Prisoners From Namangan
- RAHIMOV, PAZLIDDIN. Resided in the qishloq (village) of Girvon. Sentenced, likely in May 1999, by the court of the province to a prison term of unknown length.
- KHAMRABOEV, MA’RUF (born in 1975). Resided in Namangan city, Temir Yo’l kochasi (street), 1-proezd (drive), 57 (phone 6-36-02). Arrested on March 28, 1999. On May 21st, he was sentenced to nine years of imprisonment by the court of the province.
TOSHKENT: Prisoners Jailed For Close Associations With The Leaders Of Independent Islamic Movement
Five alleged followers of the "Wahhabi" movement (listed below) had been charged with "unconstitutional calls to change the existing constitutional system." Such alleged calls and activities could be in reality a peaceful advocacy of an Islamic state in Uzbekistan and possession of the related literature. The Union of Councils' Central Asian Human Rights Information Network and the Human Rights Society of Uzbekistan studied the official charges related to this case and concluded that the authorities did not present any evidence of violence or advocacy of violence in the activities of these imprisoned Islamic activists. It is believed that they are jailed for completely non-violent activities such as disseminating religious literature and related audio tapes, and for their association with Obidkhon qori Nazarov and To’lqin (Tulkin) qori (Yuldosh Ergashev, or Yo'ldoshev), well-known clergymen whom the authorities consider to be leaders of the so-called Wahhabi movement in Toshkent and in the country at large. On January 11, 1999, these prisoners were sentenced to jail terms ranging from two to twelve years.
- YUSUPOV, OLIMJON (born in 1956). Arrested in January 1998.
- ZIYAKHANOV, AKILKHON (born in 1952). Arrested in January 1998.
- ABDUSAMATOV, KHUSAN (born in 1963). Arrested on March 4, 1998.
- BEKKHODJAEV, MOVLONBEK (born in 1962). Arrested on March 15, 1998.
- IGAMBERDIEV, MAMURJON (born in 1962). Arrested on February 22, 1998.
Another Islamic activist associated with Obidkhon qori Nazarov
- MUSAJONOV, GULAMSODIQ [GULOMKODIR] (born in 1958). On October 18, 1998, he was sentenced to ten years in prison. Charged with the "possession of narcotics and explosives," spreading religious propaganda and "unconstitutional calls to change the constitutional system." Reportedly, police planted 2.5 grams of narcotics, a saber and an explosive on him. In addition, he was reportedly forced to give a bribe of $4,000 to remove "possession of an explosive" from the list of official charges against him.
ISLAMIC LEADERS ACTIVISTS IN QO'QON
- NURMATOV TOSHTEMIR [better known by his religious name MUKHAMMAD RAJAB] (born in 1953). Imam-Khatib (head) of the main mosque in Qo'qon. Arrested on August 24, 1994. Sentenced to fourteen years in prison with confiscation of property. During a search at his house, police "discovered" marijuana, several cartridges and one grenade.
- OTAJANOV [ATAJANOV], SODIQ [SADIK] (born in 1964). Arrested on August 24, 1994 and sentenced to twelve years in prison.
NAMANGAN: Members of Adolat (Justice) Islamic Militia in Namangan Jailed in 1992.
Adolat was created in 1991 in Namangan province to advocate Islamic values, combat crime and assist the authorities. Local authorities tolerated this group and even collaborated with the organization in the fight against crime. The group enjoyed popular support because its activities helped to significantly reduce crime in the province. Adolat was active in organizing several peaceful demonstrations calling for the establishment of an Islamic state in Uzbekistan. In December 1991, during the presidential election
campaign, a crowd of about ten thousand people demanded that President Karimov come to speak to them. The president went to Namangan and spoke to the crowd. Although the demonstration was peaceful, some representatives of Adolat and other groups publicly humiliated Karimov. About thirty members of Adolat were arrested in March 1992. In April 1992, a strike was organized in Namangan Machine Building Plant under the leadership of Vokhidjon Pattaev, the plant's chief manager. Some Adolat members were released, but were later jailed again. Many remain in prison. It is believed that most Adolat members were imprisoned for political reasons.
- KHAKIMOV, SATIMJON (born in 1942). Leader of Adolat, former schoolteacher of mathematics. Arrested in March 1992 and in October sentenced to eight years in prison. Later, in jail, his sentence was lengthened by three years.
- GHOFFOROV [GAFFAROV], ODILJON (born in 1961). Sentenced to seven years in prison.
- GHOFFOROV [GAFFAROV], ORIFJON. Brother of Odiljon and Olimjon Ghofforov (see: previous case above, and also case #76 below).
- DADAKHONOV, BOTIR (born in 1950). Arrested on August 21, 1992, and on October 2nd sentenced to three and a half years of prison. In December 1995, he returned home after serving his term. However, he was arrested again, reportedly on charges of having "escaped from prison." His family is in a severe financial situation.
- YUSUPOV, ADHAMJON. (born in 1970). On October 4, 1992 he was sentenced to three and a half years in prison, but he later received an additional three and a half year sentence. His family is in a severe financial situation.
- UMAROV, AHMAD (born in 1956). On September 19, 1994 sentenced to five years in prison. His vision worsened in jail. He should have been released through an amnesty, but was denied release after being accused of "violating prison rules." His family is in a severe financial situation.
NAMANGAN: Group of Islamic Activists Jailed for an Illegal (But Non-Violent) Attempt to Cross CIS Borders.
Reportedly, this attempt to cross CIS borders was non-violent. There were no reports that violators of the border crossing rules had narcotics, weapons or other prohibited items. Allegedly, these prisoners were also Adolat members
- ISLOMOV, KARIM (born in 1956). Sentenced to fifteen years in prison. He is in the Andijon jail.
- QUTBIDDINOV [KUTBITDINOV], KHUSNITDIN (born in 1973). Clergyman. Sentenced to eleven years in prison. He is in the Qarshi [Karshi] jail.
- BARATOV, ABDULLA
- MIRZAYOQUBOV, MADAMIN
NAMANGAN: Three Well Known and Well Respected Clergymen
- GHOFUROV [GHAFUROV, GAFUROV], ABDURAUF (born in 1942). Qozi [Kozi], religious leader of Farghona Valley of Uzbekistan (Namanagan, Farghona and Andijon provinces). Arrested on November 9, 1993. On May 3, 1994 he was sentenced to three years imprisonment on charges of embezzlement. He was supposed to have been released by September 1, 1994, but in jail he was charged with "possession of narcotics" (reportedly, narcotics had been planted by a guard) and received an additional one and a half year sentence. He was not released when he finished serving both of these two terms. He most likely received an additional term. His relatives are afraid to speak with human rights monitors and independent journalists. His son was also arrested (see below case #109).
- UZRUKKHONOV, UMARJON (born in 1955). Imam-Hatib, head of the main mosque in Namangan. Arrested on November 9, 1993 and originally sentenced to three years imprisonment. On December 20, 1994 he was sentenced to three more years. There were reports that he has received an additional sentence since then.
- RUSTAMOV, BILOLKHON. Imam-Khatib (Chief clergyman) of the biggest mosque Sheihk Eshon in Namangan. Arrested on May 23, 1998. When he was getting medical treatment in the hospital that belongs to the Gas Company of the province, Rustamov was invited to police headquarters. His brother Valikhon Bakhodirov brought him to the police station, but he was arrested upon arrival. At the same time, about twenty police officers came to Rustamov’s house and conducted a search. Reportedly, there were about one hundred neighbors, relatives and friends around his house during the search. Some of these people witnessed the police planting a weapon and protested. Neighbors report that Rustamov’s house was under surveillance for about a month before his arrest.
NAMANGAN: Group of Prisoners Arrested and Sentenced After the Murder on October 31, 1996 of Erkin Mamatqulov, First Deputy Hokim (Governor) of Namangan.
Human rights monitors believe that these people had no connection with the crime. According to some reports, during a campaign to investigate this crime hundreds of people were arrested.
- KHOTAMBAEV, MADAMIN (born in 1949). Arrested on November 4, 1996. Police "discovered" narcotics in his house during a search. On December 18, 1996, he was sentenced to two years imprisonment. He was supposed to have been released in November 1998.
- CHINALIEV, ABDURAHMON (born in 1960). Police "discovered" narcotics in his pocket. Sentenced to three years.
- DADAKHONOV, AKROM (born in 1969). Police "discovered" narcotics in his house.
- KAMRABOEV, ODILJON (born in 1955). Arrested on November 1, 1996 after police "discovered" narcotics in his apartment. Sentenced to one and a half years imprisonment.
- QODIROV [KODIROV], TO’LQIN [TULKIN]. Arrested on 8 November 1996. During an arrest, police "discovered" narcotics. Sentenced to one-year imprisonment. He was supposed to have been released on November 8, 1997, but reportedly he has not been released.
- [Last name is not clear] NURITDIN, oghli [son of NURITDIN] ABDURASHID (born in 1961). Clergyman. Arrested on December 25, 1996. During the arrest, police "discovered" narcotics. On March 7, 1997 he was sentenced to one and a half years imprisonment. He was supposed to have been released on June 25, 1998, but reportedly he was not released.
- ISOQOV [ISAKOV], RUSTAMJON (born in 1971). Arrested in November 1996. Before his arrest, he was detained in a police station for seven days for possession of narcotics.
- TOJIBOEV, ADHAM. On November 1, 1996, at 3:30am, police searched his house. According to reports, police invited two neighbors as eyewitnesses and openly planted cartridges into his pocket. One of these neighbors, a clergyman, refused to sign the protocol of the search and said that actions of the police were immoral and illegal. A police officer then beat the clergyman and threatened that he would arrest him. After that, the clergyman signed an affidavit saying that he would tell the truth at court. Tojiboev was severely beaten in the detention center. His kidney and liver were damaged.
NAMANGAN: Group of Prisoners Arrested and Sentenced after Two Police Officers were Shot Dead on March 24, 1997 in Namangan.
Reportedly, Abduvali Yo’ldoshev [Yuldashev] shot two police officers (Major Sharifjon Tursunov and Captain Marat Toshboev) when these two officers were threatening him by aiming pistols at him. Yo’ldoshev left Uzbekistan and in 1998 told his story on Radio Liberty’s Uzbek program.
- GHOFFOROV [GAFFAROV], OLIMJON (born in 1959, third degree invalid/disabled). Brother of Odiljon and Orifjon Ghofforov (see cases #56 and #57 above). According to his daughter, police arrested him on March 29, 1997 on the street when he was with his children. Police openly planted a pistol in his pocket. Charged with the possession of a weapon and narcotics. Sentenced to one year of imprisonment. He was supposed to have been released on March 29, 1998, but he remains in prison.
- EGAMBERDIEV, SOBITJON (born in 1964). Arrested on April 29, 1997 near Construction Plant. A search during his arrest "discovered" a rifle in his car. Reportedly, at the same time a woman came to his house and told Egamberdiev’s wife that she was taking a survey. After a brief conversation, the "guest" asked to go to the restroom. When she left the restroom, two police officers came to conduct a search and "discovered" 23 cartridges and 20 grams of narcotics in the restroom.
- GHOFUROV, KHOSHIMJON (born in 1963). Clergyman. Arrested on March 30, 1997. The day of his arrest, police brought their own eyewitnesses and conducted a search of his apartment where they "discovered" narcotics and rusty cartridges. Reportedly, the search was conducted without the authorization.
- SHARIPOV, MUKHIAMMADJON (born in 1961). Arrested on April 5, 1997 after police "discovered" 6.8 grams of narcotics and eight cartridges in his pocket. The next day, police brought eyewitnesses to Sharipov’s house and searched it. 17 grams of cocaine and 8.5 grams of marijuana were "discovered" there. On June 10, 1997 he was sentenced. There is no information on the length of his sentence. He has four children; the oldest is ten years old.
- AVLIYOKHONOV, KHASANBOY. Clergyman. Arrested in 1997 and sentenced to six years imprisonment.
- MAMADALIEV, ODIL (born in 1950). Farmer. Arrested in April 1997.
- RAHMONOV, RASULJON (born in 1966). Arrested April 7, 1997. Police "discovered" 30 cartridges and 0.8 grams of narcotics. Sentenced on June 18, 1997 to two and a half years imprisonment. "Witnesses" consisted of police officers only.
- AHMEDOV, (first name is unknown). Arrested in April 1997. During search, police "discovered" narcotics. Sentenced on June 18, 1997.
- SHOKIROV, ILHOM (born in 1963). Arrested March 25, 1997. Police "discovered" 16 cartridges and narcotics in his pockets. On June 24th, he was sentenced to one year in prison. Reportedly, in violation of the law, two judge assistants ("people’s advisors") were not present at the hearings.
- RAHMATULLAEV, NURITDIN (born in 1946). Arrested on April 13, 1997. Police broke his arms. During a search, police "discovered" pistol cartridges and narcotics.
- MIRDEDAEV, NUMONJON (born in 1934). Arrested April 7, 1997. Police "discovered" a blade and narcotics.
Namangan: Prisoners Jailed in Connection with Other Alleged Crimes.
- ASQAROV, OBODKHON (born in 1962). Arrested in the Fall of 1992 and sentenced to five years in prison for "hooliganism." The authorities refused to apply to him about ten amnesties that have been issued since then. Askarov’s term has expired, but he has not been released yet. Reportedly, he was a member of the Birlik movement.
- ISHONBOEV [ESHONBOEV], OQILBEK (born in 1962). Arrested on May 17, 1994. Sentenced to three years in prison on December 21st. He was accused of weapons possession. His term has expired but he had not been released yet. Reportedly, he was member of the Birlik movement. In addition, he was an active participant in the strike at the Namangan Machine-Building Plant in 1992, which demanded the release from jail of Adolat members (see notes before the case #55 above).
- AKHMEDOV, KAMOLKHON (born in 1954). Arrested on October 22, 1994 and sentenced for possession of weapons and narcotics.
- MURODOV, ISROIL (born in 1962). Arrested in June 1994. During a search, police "discovered" narcotics. Sentenced to seven years in prison.
- NIZOMBOEV, MUHAMMADJON (born in 1967). Arrested on April 7, 1992.
- TURGHUNOV, RAHIM (born in 1960). Sentenced to four years in prison for illegal travel abroad and possession of weapons.
- ERGASHEV, KAMOLKHON. Sentenced to five years and seven months for an allegedly illegal trip to Iran.
- PO’LATOV [PULATOV], KODIRKHON (born in 1956). Arrested on October 11, 1997. Police "discovered" three cartridges in his pocket. However, he was reportedly charged with "receiving bribes" (Article 210 of the Criminal Code) and sentenced to five years and eight months in prison. Allegedly, he was a member of Adolat. He has six children. Address of his family: Namangan city, Vorovskiy ko’chasi (street), 22-tupik (drive), 10
NAMANGAN: Two brothers of Tokhir Yo’ldoshev, Head of the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan
Tokhir Yoldoshev, leader of Adolat (see notes before case # 55 above). In March 1992, when this group was banned and about thirty its members were arrested, he and many of his followers reportedly left to neighboring Tajikistan and participated in the civil war there. Later they, along with the Tajik opposition, were based in Afghanistan. Tokhir Yo’ldoshev and Juma Namangoniy, another leader of an armed group, are considered to be a strong military commander opposed to President Karimov. According to reports, the authorities did not present proof of criminal activity by Tokhir Yo’ldoshev’s two brothers.
NAMANGAN: Prisoners Arrested During a Campaign Against "Wahhabis" After December 1997 Murder of a Police Officer.
Group of Prisoners Charged with the Serious Crimes, such as Terrorism, Through the Authorities Reportedly Did Not Present Any Evidence of Their Guilt.
These prisoners were charged with the several Articles of the Criminal Code, including 154 (participation in military conflicts abroad), 155 (terrorism), 156 (inciting inter-ethnic or inter-religious hatred), 159 (unconstitutional calls to overthrow the government), and 161 (organization of a criminal group) of the Criminal Code.
Other Prisoners Jailed Before the February 16, 1999 Toshkent Bombings
NAMANGAN
ANDIJON
The following three brothers were arrested for alleged membership in the Akromiy, an Islamic group.
Members of the Hisbi-Al-Tahrir party in Toshkent
Most of these prisoners had been charged under articles 159 (conspiracy to forcibly overthrow the constitutional government), 248 (illegal possession of weapons), and 276 (illegal possession of narcotics) of the Criminal Code. They were sentenced in April-May 1999.
Other Prisoners From Toshkent
Prisoners From Khorazm Province
OTHER POSSIBLE POLITICAL PRISONERS JAILED AFTER FEBRUARY 16th BOMBINGS IN TOSHKENT
PRISONERS FROM NAMANGAN
PRISONERS FROM ANDIJON
Alleged members of the Hisbi-AL-Tahrir party, sentenced to long term imprisonment
THREE PRISONERS FROM QUQON
On May 14, 1999, the Namangan province’s court sentenced these three Islamic activists.
The case of the fourth defendant at this trial, was sent for re-investigation (reportedly, he is still in jail):
ALLEGED MEMBERS OF THE HISBI-AL-TAHRIR PARTY IN FARGHONA PROVINCE
All were charged under article 159, part 1 (calls to forcibly overthrow the constitutional government).
These three residents of Farghona city were arrested on suspicion that they were connected to the Hisbi-Al-Tahrir party. By some reports, they were students at the Farghona University.
Prisoners From Toshkent
Prisoners From Khorazm
The following prisoners were arrested in Gurlan, Shovot, Qo’shko’pir and other Districts, and in Posyolok Kosmoobod in Khiva, of Khorazm Province. They are charged under article 159 (conspiracy to forcibly overthrow the constitutional government) and some other articles of the Criminal Code.
ADDDITIONAL LIST OF ALLEGED MEMBERS OF HIZBI-AL-TAHRIR PARTY
Most of these prisoners were sentenced under the article 159 (calls for or conspiracy to forcibly overthrow the constitutional government) of the Criminal Code. The information reported in this section had been collected by members of the Human Rights Society of Uzbekistan and the Independent Human Rights Organization of Uzbekistan, and also by Human Rights Watch.
TOSHKENT