The reaction of social media users to the surprise resignation of Kazakhstan’s president has covered the whole gamut from shock to joy and solemn tribute to cynical joke-cracking.
Astana resident Yuliana Zhikhor said she sees the departure of Nursultan Nazarbayev as the end of era.
“He is the builder of our state. Strong, recognized all over the world and untroubled by civil (or any other) conflict. Thank you Elbasy,” Zhikhor wrote on Facebook, referring to the lifetime honorific meaning “Leader of the Nation” that endows Nazarbayev with considerable influence.
There was anxiety about the future as some struggled to understand what this unprecedented political event might mean.
Baurzhan Suleimenov, who also comes from Astana and heard about the resignation from a passerby in the street, admitted that his first thought was, “and what now?”
“Should I withdraw all my money from [my] bank card?” he thought to himself.
Almaty resident Svetlana Khan was just as confused. “You don’t even know whether this is a good or a bad thing,” she wrote.
The disbelievers were out in force too. Nazarbayev has, after all, been in power for three decades. And his imminent departure from office has been predicted so often that like the villagers in the fable about the boy who cried wolf, many were understandably incredulous at first.
“Is this true? Maybe this is a dream? Or maybe it is reality,” wrote Yerlan Dekelbayev, who in his youth participated in the Almaty anti-Soviet riots of December 1986.
Truth be told, however, the sheer volume of joyful reactions was startling and may be worrying news for those would seek to ride off the coattails of Nazarbayev’s legacy.
But as Almaty doctor Marat Kiyashev noted ruefully, it is not as though people could celebrate on the streets of his city as this would be taken as an “unsanctioned rally.”
“If I become president, I promise to move Independence Day from December 16 to March 19,” he joked.
Amir Shaikezhanov raised a glass of wine in tribute to Nazarbayev’s abdication with the words: “I don’t know what tomorrow will bring, but today I drink. Cheers!”
Commenters under the Facebook post then posted their own glasses and exchanged messages of congratulation.
Public relations worker Samat Dzhamayev said his messenger was filling up with expressions of overbrimming emotion.
“This is first time the people of Kazakhstan have been so happy. People are congratulating one another. How could they have driven people to the point that there would be this reaction?” he wrote.
It is, of course, dangerous to read too much into this. People feel always feel more emboldened to be mischievous on the internet. Still, as blogger Arman Daniel mused, you have to wonder how this squares with Nazarbayev’s performance in the 2015 election, when he is supposed to have won 97.7 percent of the vote.
Pundits, meanwhile, played it cool, explaining to their followers that this really all means nothing at all.
“Nobody is going anywhere! Stop fomenting your illusions,” wrote opposition journalist Sergei Duvanov. “Nazarbayev will remain chair of the national Security Council and will continue to rule over the country in a new capacity.”
Anybody awaiting change should expect disappointment, he added sourly.
Almas Sadykov likewise argued that the system was not changing materially. The resignation performance was just that — a good show, he said.
Galym Ageleuov, who has been on the frontline of rights activism for many years, was similarly sanguine.
“I can hear fireworks (?) outside the window in Almaty. Young people who have known only one president all their lives are joyful and asking: ‘What will come next?’” Ageleuov said. “Nazarbayev has just moved into another seat!”
Large numbers chose to process the shock and joy through humor.
Berdymukhamedov: Hey hey, fellas, have you heard the news?
Lukashenko: What? Who?
Putin: No way! Rumors! Himself? No way, couldn’t be.
Kim: Oh fudge, that’s allowed?
New jokes are already doing the rounds. One dwells on the commonly held impression that Nazarbayev’s interim successor, Kassym-Jomart Tokayev, who is required by his post as chairman of the Senate to take over, will just be a figurehead while the outgoing president pulls the strings from behind the scenes.
Nazarbayev gives Tokayev a new car, but it doesn’t have a steering wheel.
“But Nursultan Abishevich, where is the steering wheel?”
“Don’t you worry about that. You just press the gas, I will do the steering.”
A Facebook user going by pseudonym Alois Onomatolog joked that Nazarbayev would never really be able to leave his people.
“We are his children, grandchildren, even great-grandchildren. You think he would just up and leave us?!”
And what political event could come and go without the proliferation of memes.
One shows a screenshot of Nazarbayev’s resignation speech with words reminiscent of the ice bucket challenge craze of a few years back: “I throw down this challenge to my friends — V.V. Putin and [longtime Belarusian President] A.G Lukashenko.”
Another saw an image of Nazarbayev posted next to that of his No. 1 foe, the exiled opposition gadfly Mukhtar Ablyazov, as the latter says: “Damn! And what am I supposed to do with my time now?”
The idea of a president leaving the scene is considered pretty standard in Kyrgyzstan, which has seen a whopping five presidents since independence (two of those presidents were overthrown, but still…).
So some in Kazakhstan, like Twitter user @sula_manchester asked for advice: “Dear Kyrgyz, tell us what we should do when a president leaves, because to be honest, we don’t have a clue.”
The responses duly arrived, but were not wholly encouraging. One suggested Kazakhs should “pray that the next one is not even worse.” Another said they could “wait five years and try again” — a reference to the lapse of time between Kyrgyzstan’s revolutions in 2005 and 2010.
The posts and tweets kept up through the night and into the next day. And they can be expected to continue many more days yet. Quirky decisions like Tokayev’s sycophantic announcement that the capital, Astana, would soon be renamed Nursultan is only but more grist to the mill.
It will take longer perhaps for this all to sink in, as Astana Twitter user @champagne8th reflected.
“This world does not feel real to me without Nazarbayev. It is like Astana is no longer Astana. It is like snow is no longer snow.”
Almaz Kumenov is an Almaty-based journalist.
Sign up for Eurasianet's free weekly newsletter.
Almaz Kumenov is an Almaty-based journalist.