Skip to main content

Eurasianet

Main Menu

  • Regions
  • Topics
  • Media
  • About
  • Search
  • Newsletter
  • русский
  • Support us
X

Caucasus

Armenia
Azerbaijan
Georgia

Central Asia

Kazakhstan
Kyrgyzstan
Tajikistan
Turkmenistan
Uzbekistan

Conflict Zones

Abkhazia
Nagorno Karabakh
South Ossetia
Transnistria

Eastern Europe

Belarus
Moldova
Russia
The Baltics
Ukraine

Eurasian Fringe

Afghanistan
China
EU
Iran
Mongolia
Turkey
United Kingdom
United States
X

Arts and Culture

Economy

Politics

Kazakhstan 2022 unrest
Kyrgyzstan 2020 unrest

Security

Society

American diplomats in Central Asia
Coronavirus
Student spotlight
X

Visual Stories

Audio
Video

Blogs

Tamada Tales
The Bug Pit

Podcasts

Expert Opinions
The Central Asianist
X
You can search using keywords to narrow down the list.
Kyrgyzstan

Kyrgyzstan: Manas Rebranding Drive Stirs Worries About Money, Nationalism, Scorn

Chris Rickleton Aug 18, 2011
image All Manas, all the time in Kyrgyzstan? (Photo: Dean C.K. Cox)

In the weeks since Kyrgyzstan’s authorities tore down a monument to freedom in Bishkek’s central square, vowing to replace it with a statue of the legendary Manas, a campaign to rename the capital after the mythical hero is gaining momentum. But how much Manas can Kyrgyzstan handle?

Historians cast doubt over the existence of Manas, the title character of an oral epic sung by revered elders. But to do so in domestic political circles is tantamount to heresy: Manas is the ultimate national symbol, the cornerstone of a pre-Soviet, pre-Islamic, nomadic Kyrgyz identity.

As a presidential race competes in fanfare with the country’s 20th anniversary of independence on August 31, populist politicians are indulging in another round of what a local blogger calls “Manas mania.” And the phenomenon may have serious implications for the beleaguered state budget and the country’s fragile ethnic harmony.

Bolstered by one of President Roza Otunbayeva’s advisors, the renaming proposal – which neither the government nor the mayor backs, according to local press reports – has gained support among some academics and ordinary Kyrgyz, who see it as an opportunity for a national revival. Elmira Kuchumkulova, an anthropologist at the University of Central Asia in Bishkek, argues that the epic, which fans boast is the longest in history, could be harnessed as a “source of unity” after a year of events that threatened the very existence of the impoverished, divided state.

“The value of the epic lies in the idea of the hero that united all the Kyrgyz tribes,” Kuchumkulova told EurasiaNet.org. “That is the idea that state officials who support this [renaming] idea are using -- Manas as someone who united a nation.”

However, Kuchumkulova, who has translated parts of the epic into English, acknowledges it is “poorly understood.” Passed orally until it was first committed to paper by Russian ethnographers, the tale is vulnerable to revision and manipulation.

The country’s first president, Askar Akayev, emphasized the myriad tribal identities of Manas’ soldiers, his posse of international advisors and his cosmopolitan taste in wives. The epic subsequently earned the attention of UNESCO, which declared 1995 the “Year of Manas.” Statues of the hero appeared across the country, and one of Bishkek’s main thoroughfares was renamed after him, along with the country’s main airport (currently home to a US military base, schools, a university, and cultural centers).

In the nationalist political climate, however, ethnically inclusive aspects of the epic have been ignored and Manas is celebrated as the consummate Kyrgyz hero, not a hero for all who live in Kyrgyzstan. A major advocate of the name change, presidential advisor Topchubek Turganaliev, has a track record of proposing controversial legislation that seeks to grant ethnic Kyrgyz greater rights than minorities. Turganaliev has also referred to Kyrgyz who don’t speak the language as “not full-blooded.”

In addition to noting that Manas bears little significance for the 30 percent of the population that belong to minority groups, many commentators are appalled by the potential financial consequences of renaming the capital - again.

“How many times can we rebrand?” muses Elmira Nogoibaeva, head of Polis-Asia, a think-tank. “We have already done one rebranding, after independence, 20 years ago [when the Soviet capital Frunze was renamed Bishkek]. Rebranding a second time would place a massive burden on the limited resources available to the state.” Nogoibaeva estimates the name change could cost as much as 1 billion som (roughly $22,300,000).

“All of these proclamations are connected to the [presidential] election campaigns. Each candidate is trying to make a bigger and bolder proclamation than the one before him,” Nogoibaeva continued, “instead of trying to solve the country’s problems with concrete programs.”

Manas is “a symbol of the past. We cannot transport him into the future,” she said.

Some observers also cite a separate concern – that any attempt at renaming the capital could turn Kyrgyzstan into a laughing stock.

“Even ignoring the potential cost to the national budget, there are practical implications,” a senior western aid official told EurasiaNet.org. “In diplomatic speak, it is common to substitute a country’s name with the name of its capital. So you talk about ‘Tashkent’s position’ on something or ‘Beijing’s reaction’ to a specific world event.”

If Otunbayeva or the national parliament were to endorse the proposed name change, the diplomat added, “It would be like referring to Britain as King Arthur or Greece as Hercules. Foreign officials and donors would struggle to take the government seriously.”

Chris Rickleton is a Bishkek-based journalist.

Chris Rickleton is a journalist based in Almaty.

Sign up for Eurasianet's free weekly newsletter. Support Eurasianet: Help keep our journalism open to all, and influenced by none.

Related

The rights defender who dared challenge Kyrgyzstan’s security services
Kyrgyzstan: Court acquits defendants over October 2020 unrest
Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan border, a crisscross of smuggler tunnels

Popular

Kazakhstan: Citizen journalist’s arrest decried by media rights advocates
Cheryl Reed
Uzbekistan claims shelling near Afghanistan border
Turkey looking to transit Turkmen gas via Azerbaijan
David O'Byrne

Eurasianet

  • About
  • Team
  • Contribute
  • Republishing
  • Privacy Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact
Eurasianet © 2022