Skip to main content

Eurasianet

Main Menu

  • Regions
  • Topics
  • Media
  • About
  • Search
  • Newsletter
  • русский
  • Support us
X

Caucasus

Armenia
Azerbaijan
Georgia

Central Asia

Kazakhstan
Kyrgyzstan
Tajikistan
Turkmenistan
Uzbekistan

Conflict Zones

Abkhazia
Nagorno Karabakh
South Ossetia
Transnistria

Eastern Europe

Belarus
Moldova
Russia
The Baltics
Ukraine

Eurasian Fringe

Afghanistan
China
EU
Iran
Mongolia
Turkey
United Kingdom
United States
X

Arts and Culture

Economy

Politics

Kazakhstan 2022 unrest
Kyrgyzstan 2020 unrest

Security

Society

American diplomats in Central Asia
Coronavirus
Student spotlight
X

Visual Stories

Audio
Video

Blogs

Tamada Tales
The Bug Pit

Podcasts

Expert Opinions
The Central Asianist
X
You can search using keywords to narrow down the list.

Kyrgyzstan Votes for Intolerance, Bans Finnish Investigator

George Camm May 26, 2011

Kyrgyzstan’s leaders refuse to accept the international response to last June’s ethnic violence. Responding to the latest in a series of independent studies that dare say more Kyrgyz killed Uzbeks (though it did clearly point out that Uzbeks killed Kyrgyz, too), on May 26 parliament banned the report’s author, Finnish politician Kimmo Kiljunen, from entering Kyrgyzstan. 

Not a single deputy in the 120-seat legislature was brave enough to vote against the proposal, which passed with 95 votes and one abstention. 

As Kyrgyzstan approaches presidential elections, the country is becoming a bastion of intolerance. Anyone who challenges the dominant nationalist discourse, which essentially holds that Uzbeks got what they deserved during the ethnic bloodletting -- and, by the way, members of the minority are ungrateful separatist-terrorists -- is accused of conspiring against the nation. The majority, in turn, takes increasingly drastic measures to make sure all they hear is that they are correct. 

The ban is a play straight out of detested despot Kurmanbek Bakiyev’s book. Don’t like what someone has to say? Ban them. Now, will anyone with the audacity to ask for a measured response to the violence also end up dead in a mysterious car fire? Or cast from a sixth-floor window? 

There seems enough hate going around to believe so. 

President Roza Otunbayeva has been painfully silent as politicians fall all over themselves to denounce Kiljunen and his May 3 report, where he wrote that members of Kyrgyzstan’s military took part in the ethnic violence, and found indications they committed crimes against humanity. Deputies say the report, which Otunbayeva commissioned, incites interethnic discord.

Parliamentary Speaker Akmatbek Keldibekov, leader of the virulently nationalist Ata-Jurt Party, has said repeatedly that the report is biased. He blames “separatists” for the violence – a clear reference to minority ethnic Uzbeks. Unfortunately, since it is doubtful many Kyrgyzstanis have read the whole 89-page report, most will believe the interpretations of such illustrious public figures, no mater how one-sided. For the record, the report does not say only one ethnic group attacked the other.

Nevertheless, Keldibekov, repeating his government’s response, declared at a meeting of post-Soviet parliamentary assemblies on May 16 that he could not stomach the charges: “We do not accept the tendency, which takes into consideration the crimes committed only by members of one ethnic group, ignoring its losses, and presents another group as defenseless victims.” 

(The international studies, including reports by Human Rights Watch and the International Crisis Group, dismiss the separatist fear mongering). 

The May 26 vote included a provision tasking the Interior Ministry with prosecuting those disseminating “false information.”

What about deputy Jyldyz Joldosheva's irresponsible rants? On May 25, she screened a “documentary” claiming that “The first days of the tragedy demonstrated the preparedness of the Uzbek separatists,” and, “Today Uzbeks themselves admit they started the June tragedy.”

They do? Oh, but it doesn’t matter: You are a public figure. People believe you. Who cares about truth and reconciliation?  

 

Sign up for Eurasianet's free weekly newsletter. Support Eurasianet: Help keep our journalism open to all, and influenced by none.

Popular

Kazakhstan: Citizen journalist’s arrest decried by media rights advocates
Cheryl Reed
Uzbekistan claims shelling near Afghanistan border
Turkey looking to transit Turkmen gas via Azerbaijan
David O'Byrne

Eurasianet

  • About
  • Team
  • Contribute
  • Republishing
  • Privacy Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact
Eurasianet © 2022